Search articles

Press Esc to close · Enter to search

Versus

Honest head-to-head comparisons of popular home products. We test so you don't have to.

26 articles 3,692 reads

A vs B — Honest Comparisons

We tested both. Here are the wins, the losses, and who each is for.

Product A

luxury vinyl plank

I installed luxury vinyl plank in one rental and laminate in another and lived in both. The resale gap is twenty-eight hundred dollars and the noise gap was twice what I expected.

Read full review →
Product B

laminate flooring

See the article for the full comparison.

See how they compare →
Product A

bidet attachment

I installed a thirty-two dollar bidet attachment and tracked every roll of toilet paper in my apartment for ninety days. The savings surprised me, the comfort complaint did not.

Read full review →
Product B

toilet paper

See the article for the full comparison.

See how they compare →
Product A

window air conditioner

I installed a window unit and a portable AC in two Indianapolis apartments and ran them through a full July. The portable lost on noise, the window lost on lease rules.

Read full review →
Product B

portable AC

See the article for the full comparison.

See how they compare →
Product A

smart lock

I installed a smart lock on my apartment door in 2022 and replaced it in 2024. The first cost me four hundred dollars in deposit deductions, the second survived a move.

Read full review →
Product B

traditional lock

See the article for the full comparison.

See how they compare →
Product A

apartment carpet

Two apartments, two leases, four years in Louisville. Six categories, one clear winner, and one trapdoor most renters miss. The cleaning cost number alone swung the answer.

Read full review →
Product B

hardwood floor

See the article for the full comparison.

See how they compare →
Product A

smart light bulb

I swapped half my bulbs to smart and half to regular LEDs for six months. The electric bill difference was $47, the convenience real, and one group of renters should skip.

Read full review →
Product B

regular LED bulb

See the article for the full comparison.

See how they compare →
Product A

Cyber Monday apartment deals

Cyber Monday apartment deals tested by a Chicago renter. Nine things I bought, four worth keeping, five returned by January, and the verdict on each item by category and price.

Read full review →
Product B

regular Amazon Prime Day deals

See the article for the full comparison.

See how they compare →
Product A

Black Friday apartment deals

Black Friday vs Cyber Monday for apartment deals, tracked over five years from my San Francisco rental. The 3-category winner by item type, and the day I'd skip as a renter.

Read full review →
Product B

Cyber Monday apartment deals

See the article for the full comparison.

See how they compare →
Product A

Electric Kettle

My dorm kitchen has two hot plates and no room for an appliance. An electric kettle vs stovetop apartment test across counter space, boil time, and one fire.

Read full review →
Product B

Stovetop Kettle

See the article for the full comparison.

See how they compare →
Product A

Thermostat Knob

The smart thermostat sat in a box for a year because the wires were not there. A thermostat knob vs smart thermostat rental timeline, and where the savings went.

Read full review →
Product B

Smart Thermostat

See the article for the full comparison.

See how they compare →
Product A

Wool Socks

I wore both for three weeks in the same cold apartment and the cotton pair felt colder, which made no sense until I understood what wet cotton does to a foot. Here is the.

Read full review →
Product B

Cotton Socks

See the article for the full comparison.

See how they compare →
Product A

Plug-In Meter

I spent a winter trying to work out why my flat was cold from a bill that only told me a total. A meter told me in one afternoon that the problem was a fridge I had never once.

Read full review →
Product B

Reading the Bill

See the article for the full comparison.

See how they compare →